By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
Independent News ExpressIndependent News Express
  • Home
  • International
    InternationalShow More
    France Set To Deport Women Found In Lorry
    2 days ago
    Three Killed As Shootings Rock Rotterdam City
    2 days ago
    Haiti Crisis: Can Kenyan Police Officers Defeat The Gangs?
    2 days ago
    Kenya confident its police will end Haiti gang war
    Kenya Confident Its Police Will End Haiti Gang War
    3 days ago
    Advisory Committee Meets In DR Congo To Mobilise Financial Resources In Support Of Global Biodiversity Plan
    5 days ago
  • Africa
    Africa
    Show More
    Top News
    South Africa: North West Health Denies Reports Of Severe Medication Shortages In Facilities
    1 year ago
    United Nations Tasks Ghana Govt On Mental Health Care
    8 months ago
    Africa Climate Change Finance, Time For Private Sector Support
    5 months ago
    Latest News
    Democracy In West Africa in Danger, Ghana President Cries Out
    12 hours ago
    US Suspends Aid To Gabon In Wake Of Coup
    3 days ago
    West Africa Must Be Rid Of Illicit Drug Syndicates – Tinubu
    4 days ago
    Ethiopian Prince Alemayehu’s Lock Of Hair Returned After 140 Years In UK
    1 week ago
  • Politics
    Politics
    Show More
    Top News
    Tinubu: Abdulmalik, Olonisakin, Buratai, Others Visit Lagos, Meet Lagos Speaker
    9 months ago
    Olopade celebrates Daniel’s APC Victory In Ogun
    7 months ago
    Democracy In Africa In Crisis, Afrobarometer Warns
    6 months ago
    Latest News
    Labour Party Loses Again In Lagos, Tribunal Upholds APC Rep’s Victory In Apapa
    3 weeks ago
    100 Days In Office: No Regrets Supporting Oborevwori In Delta – Latimore
    3 weeks ago
    Timi Frank Blasts Shettima For Gloating Over Predetermined Tribunal Judgement
    3 weeks ago
    Tinubu Applauds Unity In Nigeria’s Diversity
    3 weeks ago
  • News
    • Agriculture
    • Breaking News
    • Tech
    • Maritime
    • Crime
    • Culture
    News
    Show More
    Top News
    Pa Abdulfatah Amoo Ayanwale
    Pa Ayanwale Dies At 76, Fidau Prayers Holds 8 August
    2 months ago
    Ondo Governor, Akeredolu Begins Construction Of First Flyover In Akure
    2 months ago
    Lagos Blue Rail Line Nears Completion, As Engineers Launch Final Track Beam
    1 year ago
    Latest News
    Nigeria: Federal Government Committed for Country’s Data Harmonization
    1 day ago
    Tinubu To Oyedepo @69: Your Ministry Promote Humanity
    3 days ago
    Nigerian Army Begins Recruitment
    4 days ago
    Prince H.O. Mohammed Felicitates With First Lady Oluremi Tinubu At 63
    5 days ago
  • Sports
    Sports
    Show More
    Top News
    Nigeria Football
    Naija Super 8 Out To Do Things Differently, Not Competing With NPFL Super 8
    2 months ago
    Why We’re Organising Buquenson Summer Camp, Coaches Seminar In Ogun – Organiser
    5 months ago
    Samjason Football Club
    Ikeja DFA Super League: Samjason Coach Hails Players After Home Win
    2 months ago
    Latest News
    Our Plan For Young Lagos Boxers After Asaba 2023 NYG – Coach
    9 hours ago
    After Gold Miss In Asaba, Lagos Boxers Focus On Future.
    12 hours ago
    In Lagos, We Operate Modern Sports Administration – Aiyepeku
    1 day ago
    Osimhen Our Technical Asset – Napoli
    2 days ago
  • Entertainment
    • Comedy
    • Movies
    • Music
    • Television
    • Concert & Events
    Entertainment
    Show More
    Top News
    Big Brother Naija & 6 Other Reasons To Stay Connected To Your GOtv 
    1 year ago
    Big Brother Titans: 22 Titans Left To Battle For The Ultimate Prize
    8 months ago
    Meet Nigerian Idol Season 8 Top 10 Contestants 
    4 months ago
    Latest News
    Africa Magic @ 20: MultiChoice Offers GOtv Supa+ Customers Access to Africa Magic Showcase
    1 day ago
    Sound Of Praise To Raise Altar Of Praise For God – Chinedu Ezenwa
    2 days ago
    All Africa Music Awards Mourns Mohbad
    6 days ago
    Sanwo-Olu Invites DSS To Join Probe Of MohBad’s Death
    2 weeks ago
  • Lifestyle
    • Fashion
    • Love & Life
    • Food & Drink
    • Travel & Tourism
    • Relationship
    • Sex
    Lifestyle
    Show More
    Top News
    10 World’s Best Relocation Destinations
    1 year ago
    Lagos Ministry Of Tourism Engages Stakeholders In Creative Industry
    3 weeks ago
    25m Nigerians At High Risk Of Food Insecurity In 2023
    9 months ago
    Latest News
    Lagos Ministry Of Tourism Engages Stakeholders In Creative Industry
    3 weeks ago
    Isese: Court Summons IGP, Kwara Govt, Others Over Detained Traditionalists
    1 month ago
    Ilara-Epe Kingdom To Confer Chieftaincy Title On Trinidad and Tobago Envoy
    3 months ago
    Radisson Hotel Group Announces Three New Hotels In Nigeria
    3 months ago
  • Business
    • Banking & Finance
    • Oil & Gas
    BusinessShow More
    Scan to Pay
    South Africans Can Now Scan To Pay With Crypto
    2 days ago
    SCF Chain For Launch In Lagos
    3 days ago
    Fluenta Technology Supports Nigeria’s Efforts To Reduce Flare Gases
    4 days ago
    TelCables Nigeria Launches Clouds2Africa Node In Nigeria
    1 week ago
    Mele Kyari
    NNPC GMD, Kyari To Outline Nigeria’s Oil And Gas Prospects At African Energy Week 2023
    1 week ago
  • Health
    Health
    Show More
    Top News
    Marburg Virus: Ghana Records Third Death
    1 year ago
    Ilera Eko Social Health Plan Extends Scope To More Benefits For Lagos Govt Staff
    8 months ago
    Boyfriend Gives Mother And Child HIV
    5 months ago
    Latest News
    Safe Abortions Give Ghanaian Doctor Award
    2 days ago
    WHO Raises Hypertension Alert, Says One In Three Adults Affected Globally
    1 week ago
    South African-led Health Organisations Rally Washington, D.C. To Reauthorise PEPFAR To End HIV As Public Health Threat By 2030
    2 weeks ago
    Lions Club Donates Ophthalmic Equipment To LASUTH
    2 weeks ago
  • More
    • Aviation/Transportation
    • Deliverance Hour
    • Industry & Labour
    • Insurance
    • Interview
    • Judiciary
    • Metro
    • Opinion
    • Property
    • Religious
    • Romance
    • Science & Discovery
Reading: An Open Letter To The Chief Justice of Nigeria On Transparency And Accountability In Court Proceedings by Adebowale Aluko
Share
Notification Show More
Aa
Independent News ExpressIndependent News Express
Aa
  • Home
  • International
  • Africa
  • Politics
  • News
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
  • Lifestyle
  • Business
  • Health
  • More
Search
  • Home
  • International
  • Africa
  • Politics
  • News
    • Agriculture
    • Breaking News
    • Tech
    • Maritime
    • Crime
    • Culture
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
    • Comedy
    • Movies
    • Music
    • Television
    • Concert & Events
  • Lifestyle
    • Fashion
    • Love & Life
    • Food & Drink
    • Travel & Tourism
    • Relationship
    • Sex
  • Business
    • Banking & Finance
    • Oil & Gas
  • Health
  • More
    • Aviation/Transportation
    • Deliverance Hour
    • Industry & Labour
    • Insurance
    • Interview
    • Judiciary
    • Metro
    • Opinion
    • Property
    • Religious
    • Romance
    • Science & Discovery
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
  • Advertise
© 2022 Foxiz News Network. Ruby Design Company. All Rights Reserved.
Independent News Express > Blog > Judiciary > An Open Letter To The Chief Justice of Nigeria On Transparency And Accountability In Court Proceedings by Adebowale Aluko
Judiciary

An Open Letter To The Chief Justice of Nigeria On Transparency And Accountability In Court Proceedings by Adebowale Aluko

Last updated: 2023/05/27 at 5:03 PM
4 months ago
Share
SHARE

My Lord,

I write, as a concerned member of the Nigerian bar, regarding a subject which has generated controversy among members of the bar and indeed the larger public in the past week.

Confidence in the judiciary is at an all-time low.  On 22 May 2023, at the opening ceremony of the annual conference of the National Association of Women Judges, Your Lordship urged judges sitting in election petition matters across the country to do substantive justice and eschew technicalities, in order to restore the confidence of the public in the judiciary. It is against this backdrop that I write in relation to the directive of the Presidential Election Petition Tribunal (PEPT), prohibiting mobile phones and other electronic devices from the courtroom.

- Advertisement -
Ad imageAd image

 As campaign activities towards the presidential elections kicked off officially last year, the longsuffering people of this country were once again presented with an opportunity to change the trajectory of our country. The country has suffered severe economic woes and an unusual level insecurity in the past couple of years. Even judicial officers have been kidnapped! For this reason, the February 25 election was regarded by most as a pivotal moment in our history.

In spite of the electoral reforms introduced by the National Assembly through the promulgation of the Electoral Act 2022, and the allocation over N300 billion to the electoral process, we witnessed widespread violence and electoral malpractice reminiscent of the 1964/65 elections.

The electoral process and the result have been challenged in court by the two main aggrieved parties, the People’s Democratic Party (PDP) and the Labour Party(LP). Given the public importance of the case, the PDP and LP requested for a live telecast of the proceedings. On 22 May, 2023, the PEPT dismissed these applications, citing the non-existence of a procedural framework for the requests. One cannot but wonder why there needs to be a specific provision in the Rules of Court, Practice Directions, or any other procedural framework in order to allow a live telecast of court proceedings, and why such a request could not be granted under the inherent jurisdiction of the court.

It was merely a request for a greater degree of transparency than we may be accustomed to. Granting such a request does not entail any extraordinary measures beyond directing the media houses who are interested in providing the live coverage to liaise with the court registrar ahead of court sittings to ensure that it is carried out in an orderly manner. In the spirit of transparency, other African jurisdictions have livestreamed court proceedings of national importance including election petition matters.

On a related note, the PEPT had directed on 19 May 2023, that from Monday 22 May 2023, mobile phones and other electronic devices would not be allowed into the courtroom. On 22 May 2023, when court officials sought to enforce this restriction, a heated argument ensued. Subsequently, a loud protest followed. Eventually, the court officials backed down and litigants and lawyers were allowed into the courtroom with their devices.

In the middle of proceedings, the issue was raised again by the presiding judge, Justice Haruna Tsammani who sternly reiterated his position, stating that it is in the best interest of the court not to allow electronic devices into the court. He did not explain how silent mobile phones or electronic devices will prejudice the sitting of the court. He once again directed that, phones and electronic devices will not be allowed into the courtroom in subsequent proceedings from 30 May 2023.

From all indications, the concern of the PEPT regarding the presence of mobiles and electronic devices in the courtroom has little or nothing to do with the possibility of those devices ringing or disrupting proceedings. If this is the concern, there are effective ways to deal with it. Going by the latest warning of Justice Tsammani, it appears that the prohibition stems out of the concern about real time updates on the proceedings emanating from the court, and the prospects of verbatim transcripts emanating from outside the court registry.

One may therefore conclude that the real motive behind the restriction is a desire to maintain a monopoly over the record of proceedings. This is extremely disturbing for a number of reasons.

First, transparency is one of the hallmarks of our legal tradition. There is no room for the perception of secrecy in the conduct of court proceedings. Other than proceedings conducted in camera for reasons bordering on national security, state secrets and related concerns, our courts have no business restricting the use of silent electronic devices merely for the fear that proceedings – which are meant to be public anyway – will be recorded.

At a time when the judiciary is seeking to restore the confidence of the public, the court should not create a new and dreadful culture of secrecy. A dangerous precedent will be set for mischievous judicial officers in the lower courts who wish to manipulate court records.

Even if one argues that the proceedings cannot be said to be secret on the basis that the general public is allowed into the courtroom, going to great lengths to prohibit silent electronic devices for fear that the proceedings will be captured on tape is already generating negative inferences.

Secondly, in this digital age, it is now the norm for lawyers to use electronic files and libraries. This practice became more popular with the Covid-19 lockdown. These days, many lawyers prefer to use a tablet for their courtroom work as this obviates the need to carry numerous physical files and volumes of books. Lawyers have been using these devices silently in court without any form of disturbance to the court for years.

Therefore, the prohibition which the PEPT seeks to impose will place an unnecessary burden on lawyers to return to the Stone Age. More importantly, prohibiting the use of silent electronic devices which do not disturb, disrupt or interfere with the proceedings of court in any manner, potentially violates the right to personal liberty of lawyers. To adopt the language of section 45 of the Constitution, there is no reasonable justification for such a restriction, especially in a supposed democratic society, in the instant case.

 On the premise of the foregoing, I respectfully appeal to Your Lordship to preserve the openness and transparency which exist in Nigerian courts, and the right of lawyers to the use of technology in a decorous manner, in the conduct of their cases in all courts and tribunals across the country.  

*   *   *   *   *   *   *   *   *   *

Adebowale Aluko can be reached at [email protected]. The letter was originally published in the West Africa Weekly by David Hundeyin

You Might Also Like

We Already Knew What Would Happen, Labour Party Faults ‘Strange’ Tribunal Judgement

Court Orders UBA To Pay Damages To Ex- Staff For Unlawfully Account Freezing

Fela Seton, NF Branding and Oduola Oladele Lose Property Over Judgment Debt of Over N93, 071m

Lagos SWAN: National Industrial Court Reschedules Judgement To 13 December

TAGGED: Chief Justice of Nigeria
INadminNG May 27, 2023 May 27, 2023
Share This Article
Facebook Twitter Whatsapp Whatsapp LinkedIn Telegram Email Print
Previous Article World Cup: NFF Scribe Splashes Cash On Flying Eagles
Next Article Hi-Life Fest: Quest For Next King Of High Life Music Begins As Show Enters Eviction Stage
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

about us

Independent News Express (iNews Express), a publication of 4Ds Nigeria Limited, is birthed out of the desires of the founding fathers to report News as it is.

We value Professionalism, Excellence, Service, Creativity and Integrity.

The Company

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy & Policy

Quick Links

  • Advertise with us
  • Newsletters
  • Deal

Categories

Find Us on Socials

© Independent News Express. All Rights Reserved.
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?